top of page
Search

Nishine Lure Works Erie 115MD: 10 Years of Development

Writer: Outdoor Actibu
Outdoor Actibu
Jan 19, 2023
11 min read

Updated: Oct 30

This is a translation of the article Hiroshi Nishine wrote on his blog about the 10-year development of the Erie 115MD. We really wanted to share this story.


His original blog (Japanese): https://beatour.exblog.jp/



Nishine Lure Works Erie 115MD: 10 years of development


In today's blog, I'd like to look back on the 10-year development of the Erie 115MD.


Here, step by step, is the story of the most difficult lure I have ever developed.


October 2012: the Erie 115MD concept is born

The first wooden prototype.


April 2013: the second prototype

Wooden master model of the second prototype.


Master model used to make the urethane foam body.


I wasn't satisfied with the first prototype, so I made a second one.

This time it wasn't wood: it evolved into a urethane foam prototype.

The shape and action of the Erie 115MD were finalized with this second prototype.


2013: testing the second (urethane foam) prototype

Erie 115MD prototype with a urethane foam body.


The second prototype performed well both on the retrieve and on the jerk. It was deadly and caught lots of smallmouth on Lake Erie.

Its balance is unique: on the retrieve it swims briskly with a slight weaving motion, and a light jerk produces a lifelike darting action.


August 2013: the idea for the outer weight system

An early outer weight.


The idea for the outer weight system came from Maiki, now a professional guide on Lake Biwa, when he stayed with us in Canada.

He showed us a clip-on weight he had made to adjust the buoyancy of the Ochiayu WP.

It was just a snap with a small ball weight, but it worked on the Erie 115MD too, and the concept of the outer weight system was born.

And this idea fixed a weakness of the prototype.

The prototype was made of urethane foam, whose density varies from piece to piece, which made it very hard to get a perfect suspend.

With the new outer weight system, we could adjust each prototype: make it slow-floating, then weight it to suspend perfectly.

But at the time we only saw it as a way to fine-tune the suspend. We didn't realize how much more potential the outer weight system had.


2013–2014: hitting the limits of the foam prototype

A body damaged by intense testing.


The second foam prototype with the outer weight was as effective as ever, but the more we fished it, the more we saw its limits.

One was the variation between pieces. The outer weight compensated for it to some extent, but making the lure in urethane foam was still very difficult, and it looked almost impossible to turn into a product.


The bigger problem was durability.

Because it's a jerkbait, the hooks scrape the body with every hard, repeated jerk, and the body gets damaged in no time.

Day by day, I wanted more and more to make a jerkbait with a hollow ABS body.


October 2014: the first hollow prototype

Handmade hollow prototype No. 1.


After a lot of trial and error, we managed to make a hollow prototype, even if it was handmade.

We found that even going from a solid body to a hollow one, it could swim just as well as the second foam prototype, as long as the setup was right.


January 2015: the decision to make the Erie 115MD in hollow plastic

We started looking for a mold maker in Canada, aiming to manufacture the lure ourselves in Canada.

At the same time, with an eye on manufacturing in China, we started researching Chinese factories.


July 2015: work on the mold begins

An injection molding machine with the mold in place.

At this stage, the mold still needed plenty of improvements.

I was surprised to see how young I looked (no gray hair! lol)


A friend introduced us to a mold maker, and we finally started making the Erie 115MD molds in Canada.


September 2015: a huge muskie on the prototype

A giant muskie, the biggest fish of my life.

On the upper Niagara River.


The Hall of Fame prototype.

The hooks were bent open in the fight with that big muskie.


I caught the biggest muskie of my life on a foam prototype: 122.6 cm!

I was fishing for smallmouth when it rose up, and for a moment I thought a log was floating up.

The huge muskie rose slowly, turned its head toward the lure on the first twitch, closed the distance on the second, and on the third twitch it lightly nipped the tail hook.

It took me about 20 minutes to land it safely. It was bigger than my daughter (9 years old at the time), who was fishing with me, and she cried.


December 2015: the 100% Canadian Erie 115MD mold and prototype are finally done

100% Canadian prototypes.

Prototype No. 1 (top), without rib lines.

Later modified with rib lines (bottom).


The lip is opaque because it was made of bone-colored ABS.


The company that made our molds in Canada was so advanced that it even supplied parts to car makers, but it had never made molds for lures, so it was a real struggle. Even so, they managed to make the mold.

And that's how the first prototype of the Erie 115MD, a hollow-body lure made 100% in Canada, was born!

At this point we couldn't get clear ABS, so the prototype was made of bone-colored material.


February 2016: improvements needed on the first Canadian prototype

Testing prototypes with different balances to narrow down the ideal action.


As testing went on, we found that the first Canadian hollow prototype matched the foam prototype on the retrieve, but its darting was slightly weaker.

After a lot of investigation, we confirmed that narrowing the body from 14.5mm to 14.0mm would improve the darting.

The problem was that this change would require major surgery on the mold.


March 2016: the first mold modification

We decided to go ahead with major surgery on the mold.


Left: before the modification.

Right: after the modification.


After talking with the engineer, we found that the mold could be modified to make the body 0.5mm narrower, and we decided to rework the mold for the first time.

It was a big operation, but it worked, and the prototype's darting improved.


March 2016: the prototype is unveiled at Keepcast

NLW's first and only Keepcast exhibition.


The Erie 115MD prototype was unveiled at the Keepcast show in Nagoya, Japan.

At that point, we believed it would be on sale in Japan within the year…


September 2016: importing clear ABS

Parts finally molded in clear plastic.


Until then, the prototypes were made of bone-colored ABS, so the lips were white. We were eager to make them in clear material, but it was surprisingly hard, because that material was difficult to find in Canada.

We asked our plastic supplier to find clear ABS for us, but he said there was no demand for it in Canada, so we had no choice but to import a large amount from South Korea.


Even though we ordered the smallest possible quantity, it was a huge amount. "What if this doesn't work?" I wondered.


2016–2017: thorough testing of the 100% Canadian hollow-body Erie 115MD

Hooks tested to destruction.


At that time, I spent more than half of my fishing time testing the Erie 115MD.

All that fishing brought the outer weight system to its current form. I also discovered that by using the outer weight to make the lure slow-sinking, the jerkbait could work at depths a normal jerkbait can't reach.

That discovery took me into a whole new world of jerkbait fishing.


Alongside the fishing tests, I bought every hook that could be used on the Erie 115MD in North America, Japan and China, and tested their durability and performance.

Finally, I came across Ichikawa Fishing's hooks and was amazed by their finish and durability. After setting aside every candidate I had tested over the years, I chose Ichikawa Fishing's RC KAMAKIRI treble hooks.

More than 100 hooks were tested. With these hooks, the last piece of the puzzle was in place, and the 100% Canadian Erie 115MD was complete.


July 2017: the 100% Canadian Erie 115MD is finally complete

The Erie 115MD released as a limited edition for North America.


The Erie 115MD was finally finished, but at this point each one still had to be completed by hand in NLW's underground workshop. Production was limited, so it was only sold in North America and through our online store.


November 2017: making manufacturing more efficient

Gluing the parts: the biggest obstacle to mass production.


The Erie 115MD was finally in production, but manufacturing (especially gluing) took so much time that we started researching ultrasonic (sonic) welding to mechanize the manual gluing of the left and right halves. Mass production was impossible without it, so we worked on it day and night.

Our research showed that if sonic welding worked, manufacturing would become much more efficient, and the lure would also be much more durable.


January 2018: the decision to test sonic welding

The grandpa engineer who helped us with the sonic welding tests.


The sonic welding machine.

The lure is placed in this machine, and ultrasonic waves melt and weld the bonding surfaces together.


Sonic welding meant redesigning the parts, which meant another major operation on the mold.

And if it failed, there was no way to restore the mold, so we made the decision knowing we could ruin everything.

After much thought, we first molded several thousand Erie 115MD bodies, the version already sold in North America, just in case, and then took the gamble of modifying the mold.

But the gamble didn't pay off: no matter how many times we modified the mold, sonic welding never worked.


June 2018: the Erie 95SD project begins

The Erie 115MD had completely run aground, but the Erie 95SD, which had been in development and testing for a while, was showing good results, so we decided to mass-produce it and started making its molds.

By then we had developed the skills to make hollow plastic prototypes (still by hand) in a single step, without going through wood → urethane foam → hollow plastic as we had for the Erie 115MD.


August 2018: one last attempt at modifying the mold

Sonic welding tests with various adjustments.


A prototype that could be welded, but with a damaged weight holder.


After repeated failed attempts, we concluded that sonic welding was impossible with the 100% Canadian Erie 115MD design.

The reason: the extremely thin plastic walls of the Canadian Erie 115MD.

The thinner the plastic, the better the action, but the harder it is to bond, and we couldn't technically overcome that limit.

It also meant there was no way to sell it in Japan.

For one last try, we thickened the walls enough to allow sonic welding, but the resulting prototype had lost so much performance that it could no longer be called an Erie 115MD.

The mold became unusable, and we had to leave the large stock of unused plastic with the mold maker…


November 2018: testing of the Erie 115SD prototype begins

A 115SD prototype made by modifying the lip of a 100% Canadian Erie 115MD.


The bodies we had molded as a backup before modifying the mold were finished by hand one by one, and the Canadian Erie 115MD kept selling steadily online, in North America only.

By modifying the Erie 115MD, we created the prototype that would become the Erie 115SD.


December 2018: the Erie 95SD mold is complete

The Erie 95SD mold, started in June at our partner factory in China, is finally finished.

We had found this Chinese factory during our research since 2015, and the quality of the first model it made for us, the Chippawa RB (released in January 2018), was excellent, so we decided to make the Erie series there too.

We chose this factory because it can sonic-weld bodies with extremely thin walls, something that's normally very hard to do. And the team is extremely motivated.

The factory also has its own brand, and the fact that none of its products were copies was a key reason we chose it.

We visited the factory twice a year to give detailed guidance on things like painting techniques, to keep raising the quality.

Over time, the whole team came together to make great products, and that's what gives NLW products their quality today.


May 2019: the Erie 95SD production prototype is complete

The production prototype of the Erie 95SD is finally ready and enters final testing.


May 2019: the Erie 115SD project begins

The 115SD prototype, made by modifying a Canadian Erie 115MD, gave excellent results, so we decided to turn it into a product.

Work on the mold began.


September 2019: the Erie 115SD production prototype is complete

The Erie 115SD mold is finished, and testing begins on a prototype with production parts.


December 2019: Erie 95SD shipping begins

The Erie 95SD is complete and released simultaneously in Japan, North America and Europe!


July 2020: Erie 115SD shipping begins!

The Erie 115SD is complete and released simultaneously in Japan, North America and Europe!


February 2021: the Erie 115MD restart project

We stop making the handcrafted Erie 115MD and start seriously planning to relaunch it at our partner factory in China.

To explore this, we start researching whether an Erie 115MD is possible using a body that can be mass-produced, by modifying the Erie 115SD made at the partner factory.


March 2021: 3D parts for the modified Erie 115MD are ready, and testing begins on a handmade prototype

3D parts made by our partner factory.


A prototype made in NLW's underground workshop in Canada, based on the 3D parts.


After fine-tuning this Erie 115MD prototype, made by modifying the production Erie 115SD, we found it could deliver a perfect action, and decided to try again to produce the Erie 115MD at our partner factory.

The Canadian Erie 115MD was modified to create the 115SD, and then the 115SD was modified again to bring the Erie 115MD back to life.

A strange fate for the Erie 115MD, but the know-how we had built up with the Erie 95SD and 115SD, both already successful products, proved very useful in making its mold.

At the same time, we also started the molds for the Erie 115TW, another prototype derived from the Erie 115SD that was giving good test results.

The global Covid pandemic slowed the project down, but we kept moving forward.


March 2022: the Erie 115MD mold is finally complete!

Body parts finally complete after many twists and turns.


At the partner factory, the production mold for the Erie 115MD was finally finished, and the last stage before release began.

We assembled, tested and adjusted the final parts from the production mold, refining the final settings through round after round of fine-tuning.


June 2022: everything changes at the last minute

The final sample received from the factory.


After a long, long process of trial and error, the final production sample of the Erie 115MD was ready!

But when we happily did the final check, we found the action wasn't quite what we were aiming for…

The lure lacked stability at very high speeds, and past a certain limit it jumped out of the water. That was a real blow.

Everything else about the action was perfect. We debated whether to release it as it was or delay the release to improve it, and we chose to delay and improve.

By then the plastic body parts had already been molded. We gave them up and sent them for recycling: 3,000 parts.


July 2022: Erie 115TW shipping begins

The Erie 115TW, developed alongside the Erie 115MD, was finished first and made its debut.


September 2022: the improved Erie 115MD mold is complete

Top: prototype before the improvement.

Bottom: prototype after the improvement.

The lip angle is slightly different.


So what did giving up 3,000 bodies and reworking the mold get us?

We assembled the improved parts with a prayer and decided to livestream the final test from the lake.

Since we had never managed to successfully modify the mold of the Canadian Erie 115MD, we were full of anxiety. But the livestream test confirmed that the weak points were completely fixed. We finally finished the project with many people watching.

The final improvement was setting the lip angle at 4 degrees.


December 2022: Erie 115MD shipping begins


The birth of the Erie 115MD.


After 10 years of work, the Erie 115MD was finally complete.


I can't judge whether it's good or bad, but I can say with confidence that we did the best we could.


We hope the Erie 115MD serves you well.




 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page